TABLE OF CONTENTS:
| |
How this all started.
Sunday August 20th, 2000
Monday August 21st, 2000
Tuesday August 22nd, 2000
Thursday August 24th, 2000
Sunday August 27th, 2000
FYI, this week, Melanie, Justice and I are travelling. We will certainly
do some chess work, but likely not much. If anything really nifty
happens, I will be sure to update this page. However, I expect that
nothing will be updated here until Monday September 4th. Sorry to
anyone who is watching...
Thursday September 14th, 2000
|
|
HOW THIS ALL STARTED
| |
First of all, I should say that we
are trying to teach Justice three things currently: reading, math
and chess. Yes, chess. At the time of this writing, he is
25.5 months old - just a little over two years. This may all seem
a little ambitious, but, read on and find out why we think it is
actually quite reasonable.
Several years ago, I discovered that
my dad had a book in his collection called How
to Teach Your Baby to Read. I pilfered the book from my dad
and lugged it around while I moved from place to place for several
years. Eventually, I got married and actually had a baby. At various
times I remembered the book, but I didn't actually do anything about
it. Until Justice got to be about fourteen months old. I read the
book and was so inspired at points that I couldn't contain my joy.
I'm talking about a big lump in my throat, tears, uncontrolled laughing,
and jumping around!
Suffice it to say, I set about actually
trying to put it into practice. I used my computer and printer to
make the big block letter cards that the book recommends, starting
with "MAMA"
and "DADA"
in 288 point Helvetica. To make a long story short, it didn't take
long until he definately recognized about forty words. I spent about
five minutes a day on this and was very inconsistant - I only sort-of
followed the book's instructions. Being aware of some basic scientific
principles, I made sure to randomize the order the words were presented,
and to test his knowledge and understanding. He could speak the
word when shown it, could point to the object it represented (for
example if shown "VACUUM" he would run and get his toy
vacuum), and could pick out a requested word from a small random
pile of words.
But then after the first couple of
weeks, I started to seriously let the process slip. And eventually,
after about two months, I dropped it alltogether. Bah! I'm kicking
myself now. I came so close to failing in my sacred duty as a parent.
Over the intervening months, until a couple of days ago, I had a
nagging feeling of guilt and loss because I had neglected to do
the work properly.
Now, in the last few days, two things
have happened that have rekindled my interest in this and motivated
both myself and Melanie (my wife) to start this process again, with
even more vigor. First of all, on Friday night (Aug. 18, 2000),
we went to a bookstore. Melanie was researching home schooling and
came across another of Glen Doman's books called How
to Teach Your Baby Math. Well, lets just say that she is obsessed.
She has just finished a BA degree in developmental psychology so
she has a clue about this stuff. One aspect of this system that
has impressed her is the idea that children learn rules most effectively
by learning facts. Their brains are incredibly good at extracting
(subconciously) the rules in a domain. The best example is language:
children learn their native language and all its complicated pronounciation,
syntactic and sematic rules and exceptions incredibly quickly and
perfectly. And without any formal "rule teaching" until
well after they have reached mastery level (i.e. when they get into
school and start to learn to write). Anyway, to considerably shorten
the story, Melanie has taken on the challenge and is now systematically
applying the method recommended in the book to teach Justice math
and in a few days will return to the reading challenge as well.
The second thing that has happened
in the last few days is that Justice has taken a very strong
interest in chess. I know that seems bizarre, but it actually has
a fairly reasonable genesis. In July, Justice started watching the
DVD, A
Bug's Life (Special Edition). In the special edition package
there is a second disk that has the animation short Geri's
Game. This was shown, if I remember correctly, as a lead
to the main feature. The basic setting of Geri's Game
is at a chess table in a park. Justice must have watched this literaly
a hundered times. It is only about five minutes and there were several
days when we just put it on repeat and he sat and loved it. So last
week, we were shopping in a mall and happened into one of those
trendy we-sell-cool-around-the-house-stuff-and-executive-toys stores.
At the back they had a few chess boards and Justice just went crazy
- he really wanted to play. So we let him fiddle for a few
moments and then we had to leave (his diaper was totally soaking
and Melanie's back was really hurting).
Then on Friday, at the book store
mentioned above, I happed upon a big tome called, appropriately,
Chess
: 5334 Problems, Combinations, and Games. As soon as Justice
saw it, he kept saying "read chess? read chess?" and "chess
board". I gave it to him and he actually started flipping through
it. And he didn't get immediately bored by the thousands
of chess problem diagrams. Still, I didn't think much of his interest
at the time other than that it seemed a little unusual.
Yesterday (Saturday) Melanie and I
spent much of the day getting stuff for the math program. But again
Justice showed some interest in the chess book so I let him flip
through it. At the same time, I started to read some of the math
book and to think about what I could teach Justice using an analogous
method...
|
|
Sunday August 20th, 2000
| |
But it didn't occur to me until this
morning, when Justice yet again asked for the chess book, to seriously
consider teaching him chess. I flipped open the book to its introduction
to the pieces. I went through it very quickly with Justice,
simply naming the pieces, pointing to their graphical symbols, and
describing their behavior with words, the supplied diagrams, and
my finger. Because of one of the strongest recommendations in the
Doman books, I then immediately stopped and put the book away -
before Justice became bored with it. He put up a little tantrum,
but was calmed by being told that we would continue to learn chess
later.
We looked at the book a few more times.
Each time I reviewed the pieces. Justice can now correctly identify
the black and white pawns on the diagrams even though they are very
small and not all that different from the symbols used for the bishops.
This happened by accident. I was just pointing to pieces on the
problem diagrams and naming them. Justice, of his own accord, pointed
at the page and said "pawn". I hadn't been looking so
I wasn't sure if he had actually pointed at a pawn. But then he
did it several more times and even got more detailed by correctly
pointing to "two white pawns" and saying exactly so.
Doman's process really focuses on
teaching facts as plainly and directly as possible, so this chess
book is in some ways very well suited - all the problems are in
essence chess facts. The one-move problems are simple, demonstrate
the goal of checkmate, demonstrate a multitude of different moves,
and have only one correct solution. The real problem is how to present
these to Justice so that he can derive the rules. The chess book
has all the solutions, but they are presented in notation rather
than a before and after set of diagrams. So this evening Melanie
and I discussed how seriously we should take this and what we should
actually do.
We decided that since Melanie was
focusing on math and reading and is home with Justice the whole
day, that I should probably have my own subject to teach him and
chess seems like a nice one to start with. We figured out that we
can make "one move chess problem cards": on one side is
the problem position and on the reverse is the solution position.
So tomorrow I will do a whole bunch of photocopying at work to make
the images for the cards and we will see what happens...
|
|
Monday August 21, 2000
| |
Today was a bit odd. Unfortunately,
Melanie was sick during the night and so things were a bit out of
sorts for the day. I ended up sleeping in. When I did wake up, around
10:30, Justice was up as well, and we did a quick bit with the chess
book. Actually, really he just fiddled with the book and I watched.
Because I had plans for cards, I didn't really want to bore him
with going over the names of the pieces again. Besides, he quickly
proved that I didn't need to: he opened the book and pointed at
a rook and said "wrook" (that's my rendering of how it
sounded - he's still young enough that his pronunciation isn't all
that great). So that was a good morning gift from him to me. I packed
up the book and headed off to work.
On the way to work I phoned my best
friend Jesse and told him about Justice's newest accomplishments
(actually, I got him to read the above two journal entries :). Ahhhh...
bragging is such fun :) He was duly impressed.
At work I made a bunch of copies of a board
and the pieces. On the back of the chess book is a nice image of
a board rendered in the same manner as the diagrams for the problems
except that it is in the initial position and it is much bigger
(and therefore more suitable for enlarging and photocopying). I
measured it to be 3.5" (normally I work in centimeters, being
from Canada) on a side. I needed boards that were 5" on a side
to fit the cards that Melanie was going to make for me. So I did
the percentage calculation, programmed the photocopier and made
two enlarged copies. I then did a little cutting and pasting (actually
scotch-taping) in order to produce one empty board (no pieces) and
eight rows of pieces, four black, four white. Then I made thirty
copies each of these two items.
Once home I started to make the cards.
The basic idea I had was to put the problem setup diagram on one
side and on the other the solution. I started to cut and paste...
and boy-o-boy did it take a long time to do the first card. It didn't
help that I had made some mistakes in my photocopying and that I
had chosen a problem (#1) with quite a few pieces on the board.
I just wasn't thinking very clearly. On the solution side I also
used a yellow highlighter to highlight the piece that had moved:
a queen. I did eventually finish the first card.
I told Justice that I was going to
show him his chess card. I showed him the problem side and said
something stupid to the effect, "White has to move to kill
the black king." Gack! Anyway, I flipped it over and did a
little better, "White has moved the queen and now the black
king is checkmated." Then I gave him the card. He was very
intent. He immediately pointed at the highlighted queen and said
"white queen". I was very impressed since I hadn't told
him what it was or pointed at it myself. He also said "queen
moved" but I don't really know if he understood. After that
short chance to touch the card, I took it away and told him that
we would do more later. Doman makes it really clear that parents
should always anticipate the loss of the child's interest and make
sure that the materials are taken away while the child is still
really happy and having fun with them. This intensifies their desire
to work with the materials more.
After Justice went to bed, Melanie
helped me by doing the cutting and we made four more cards. I'm
now trying to be a little more systematic about how I present them.
All of them are simpler than the first one (only four or five pieces
in the problem). The problems are "easy" in that the move
is quite obvious to someone who knows the rules - my wife who is
an extreme novice (once reminded of the moves for the pieces) figured
out the solutions to all of them. One is a knight move, one is a
bishop move, and two are rook moves. I have to get my presentation
a little more polished. And tomorrow morning we will hopefully look
at two more.
I also need to figure out when I will
introduce him to a real chess board (probably very soon) and when
I will introduce him to some good chess software (probably after
he learns how to use the mouse better :).
|
|
Tuesday August 22nd, 2000
| |
Today wasn't nearly as productive
as the previous two days. For one thing, I left for work just as
Justice woke up in the morning. For another thing, I was very tired
and had a huge headache when I got home. However, there were still
some interesting bits and some bits that should just be recorded
"for the record".
At work I corrected a deficiency in
my previous day's photocopying by getting a bunch of king and queen
icons on the appropriate board square color (king on color, queen
on opposite color). They don't look as good as the other pieces
because they were enlarged by over 300% - I had to take them from
some of the problem diagrams which are much smaller than the board
on the back of the book.
Also while at work, Melanie phoned
to tell me that she had purchased a wooden
chess board for Justice. Apparently they went to ToysRUs.
It is quite nice: very solid board and pieces and the pieces are
reasonably shaped. Justice loves it. Mostly he just puts the pieces
on and off and moves them randomly, but he knows what a pawn is.
When I got home, he immediately took
my hand and pulled me into the dining room to see the chess board.
He wanted me to play chess with him. I set up the pieces properly
and then started a very pretend game. He wanted to be white and
so I told him to move first. He moved a2 to b4 - not exactly legal
:) but a good try. It degenerated from there, although I have decided
that I will always make legal moves even if he isn't, just to set
a good example.
I also showed him two chess cards.
The first one I spent some time on and even set up on the chess
board. He enjoyed that quite a bit. The second one I simply showed
to him extremely quickly. He played with the chess board a little
more throughout the evening and that was it.
|
|
Thursday August 24th, 2000
| |
Well, I missed a day. And to be honest,
both yesterday and today are not much to speak of. I actually spent
more time myself learning chess than teaching Justice :( I have some
software called Power Chess which is really quite good and I have
been struggling against it. My ability to think ahead is almost non-existant
and I have a hard time looking at all the possibilities of my current
situation. This means I loose pieces "accidentally" a lot.
Anyway, enough of my own problems...
Yesterday Justice finished my few initial
chess cards - I really need to make more of them. He pays close attention,
but does not seem particularly enthusiastic about them anymore. I
think he is much more interested in the chess board which is tactile.
As for the chess board, he really does
want to play with it all the time. The only problem is that he does
not play nicely: he doesn't let me lead. I have to admit that I get
impatient far more quickly than I should. Basically, what he likes
to do is to have me set the board up. Even if he lets me finish setting
it up, the process always ends the same way: he scoops aside all the
pieces and wants to do it all over again. I guess I don't really mind,
but I have to admit that this is probably my fault. The first time
we played on the board, he already had some pieces on it when I got
home. I promptly swept them off and then started to set them up properly....
Anyway, tonight I will make him several
new chess problems. I think I will show him five new ones every day.
I'm not going to worry about him showing any real progress even though
I would of course like to see it. But the fact is that, allegedly,
babies learn rules through facts and I haven't presented even close
to enough facts for him to have a hope of learning the rules. I will
continue to play with him at the chess board however he likes with
the caveat that I will never play an illegal chess move, nor set up
the board improperly. Hopefully that will be sufficient for now. |
|
Sunday August 27th, 2000
| |
Again there was a pretty serious
lull in our efforts. On Friday it was due to working and then we
had visitors in
the evening - some new friends we have made who are from Paris,
France. They stayed until Justice's bedtime so we did not have a
chance to do our chess cards nor to play. Saturday was similar:
the day was taken up with errands out of the house and then visiting
in the evening.
Today, however, was good in a couple
of ways. In the morning, I quickly grabbed the four new problem
cards and flipped through them with Justice. He was very interested
(or at least he paid close attention). Unfortunately I presented
them improperly: I showed him the solution first and then the problem
meanwhile I was talking as if it was the other way around. This
is one problem with the cards - there is no quick way of telling
which side is which. Perhaps I will color code the edges... Anyway,
I decided not to mention anything about the mistake to Justice.
I would rather he be excited about learning chess than have one
little mistake on my part screw things up.
I went into work for a while today.
When I returned, we watched
Babe which is a very nice movie. I have to admit I cried at
the end. It is so simple yet so happy. If you like feel-good movies,
I highly recommend it. Anyway... After we watched it, I did another
round of chess cards with Justice. Again he paid very close attention.
I asked him if he would like to play chess with me and he did so
we set up the board a couple of times :) I also did a set of numbers
with him (the math program that Melanie is doing) and a set of words
(the reading program). The main thing is that I try to be very enthusiastic
and very quick so that he is interested and so that he doesn't get
bored.
Tonight I have to make two more chess
problems at least, and preferably more. It is going to be a very
long process of teaching him. My dad, Garry,
read my previous day's notes and we talked about this a bit. He
suggested that I find or make a very large chess set with pieces
about half Justice's height. This will make the game more substantial
and even more tactile (and kinesthetic as well). I would like to
make one, but I probably won't until I return home to Elmvale (for
those who don't know, I am currently doing a contract for Charles
Schwab in San Francisco, but I live in a small town near Toronto
in Canada). I will however ask around to see if anyone knows about
one in the bay area (if you, dear reader, happen to know of one,
please email
me about it, thanks).
|
|
Thursday September 14th, 2000
| |
Gack!!! What a loooong delay! Finally
I am getting back to this. The long lack of writing does not mean
that nothing has happened. In fact, much has happened, but I do not
remember all the details. But here is what I can remember:
While we were away in Toronto, we didn't
really do any of this stuff with Justice. He did ask for chess once
or twice, I think, but I don't really remember for sure. Once we got
back however, he really did ask about it. We ended up playing on the
chess board for several nights over the last week and a half since
we have been back. Each time, he seems mostly interested in setting
up the board and then sweeping all the pieces off. Once we played
with moving the pieces a little. The last couple of times we played,
we played a sort of naming game where I assumed that Justice knew
the names but got him to show it: I would say "I'm going to put
a black rook on the board." The I would do it, and then I would
ask him, "what piece are you going to put on the board?"
Most of the time he would hover with his hand above the pieces for
a few seconds, grab a piece, correctly name it, and put it on the
board (not necessarily in the correct position). This allowed me to
discover that he doesn't really know what to call the king and queen,
and he often forgets the name of the rook.
All that said, he is far more interested
in the things that Melanie has been doing with him. Unfortunately
Melanie has neglected her online journal as well. So here is a very
quick summary. Justice has been learning to read through the use of
flash cards with a single word on them and no pictures. He has been
learning what Doman calls "bits of intelligence" which are
really just facts. These are flash cards with a nice large image on
them. We have cards with butterflies, the works of Van Gogh, inventors
(all men :( ), polygons (Justice now knows this word :), and some
forthcoming such as countries, authors, flags, musical instruments,
and snakes. We have also been doing number flash cards with are not
what you might imagine. They are simply a large number of red dots
on the card - as the card is flashed, the number is said and that
is it. This is to teach instant quantity recognition. Justice now
enjoys all of these things and frequently asks for them which we consider
a good sign.
I do expect to do more chess work with
Justice, but it is definately on a slower pace than the first week
:) |
|
| Incidentally, Melanie is writing a journal
of her efforts with Justice. |